At some point repairing an old outboard costs more than it's worth, and there's no guarantee the repair will last. Then the question is what to replace it with. These two videos follow the Green Machine from one motor to the next.
In this video I explain how I decide when to give up on an outboard: its age and value, and that a second-hand motor can bring problems you don't know about. The Green Machine's motor had a sheared starter motor lug on the crankcase, metal filings, seized carburettor mixture screws, a leaking gearbox, and home-made fixes everywhere. Fixing it would cost $1,000 to $2,000 in parts with no guarantee, so I take it off the boat. Where that point is depends on what you use the boat for and what problems you can live with. Taking it off the transom is the reverse of mounting an outboard.
Over dinner with friends who commute by boat, we settle on about 50HP for the Green Machine, then compare six brands from their brochures: weight, cylinders, warranty, displacement, horsepower and charging output, plus the gauges and how easy each is to service yourself. On paper there's no clear winner. They're all good outboards, and none of the brands is a lemon.
